Everything else
Nominate a venue

Find your room

Sign in to STK

or

Join this match

New match

PLAY THIS MATCH?

Get the full app

Add STK Social to your Home Screen

Opens full screen, no browser bar, and remembers your sign-in.

  1. 1Tap the Share iconIn Safari's toolbar (the square with an arrow pointing up).
  2. 2Tap "Add to Home Screen"Scroll down the share sheet if you don't see it right away.
  3. 3Tap "Add"STK Social opens full screen from your Home Screen from now on.
STKSHOOT TO KILL
POOL LEAGUE
Official

November 5, 2026 · 5 min read

Growth Mindset

Does a Growth Mindset Help You Win? What Research Says

A growth mindset helps some learners, but reviews find the average effect small. Here is what that means for your pool game and how to test it.

In 2006, psychologist Carol Dweck published Mindset: The New Psychology of Success, a book built on one claim: people who believe their abilities can grow do better than people who believe their abilities are fixed. It sounds right at a pool table, where every miss can feel like either a verdict or a lesson.

The research says the idea is real but smaller than the book makes it sound. Large reviews find a weak link to results and a small average effect from mindset programs, and scientists still argue about who benefits. Use mindset as a way to run practice, not as a promise of wins.

By the end, you will have a five-step routine that turns misses into information at your next match night, plus a fair way to check whether it helps you.

The short answer: Maybe, but less than the best-selling book suggests. Large reviews find only a weak link between believing skill can grow and results in school, and a small average effect from mindset programs. Some results hint that the benefit may be larger for struggling learners. We found no pool study, so treat it as a practice habit, not a promise.

What does the book Mindset actually claim?

Carol Dweck's Mindset: The New Psychology of Success (2006) argues that people who believe abilities can be developed flourish more than people who believe abilities are fixed. Her publisher says the idea shapes success in school, work, sports, and the arts. The book is a popular argument, not a trial, so the research has to carry the weight.

That distinction matters. A book can gather stories that fit its thesis, while a meta-analysis pools many studies, including the ones that disagree. The rest of this article leans on the second kind of evidence.

Does believing you can improve actually predict better results?

Only weakly. Sisk and colleagues pooled 273 studies and 365,915 people in Psychological Science (2018) and found a weak overall link between growth mindset and academic achievement. It is a correlation, so it cannot show the belief causes better results, and it covers school achievement, not sport.

The same paper ran a second meta-analysis of 43 studies and 57,155 people, testing whether mindset programs raise achievement. It also found a weak overall effect. Some results suggested that students with low socioeconomic status or at academic risk might gain more, though the authors present that only as a suggestion.

Do mindset programs improve results?

Sometimes, by a small amount, and scientists disagree about how much. Macnamara and Burgoyne reviewed 63 studies with 97,672 participants in Psychological Bulletin (2023) and found an average effect of d = 0.05, not significant after correcting for publication bias. Another team re-analyzed the same data and found a meaningful effect for at-risk groups.

That second team, Tipton and colleagues (Psychological Bulletin, 2023), argues that averaging everything together hides who benefits. Four of its six authors also wrote the 2019 Nature study below, so read it as one side of a live dispute. Macnamara and Burgoyne published a reply, so the question is contested, not settled.

The Nature study, led by Yeager and including Dweck among 25 authors, tested a short online program, under an hour long, on a nationally representative sample of U.S. secondary-school students. It improved grades among lower-achieving students and raised enrollment in advanced math across the whole sample. Note the pattern: the grade gains came for people who were struggling, in schools where peer norms matched the program's message.

What does this mean for a pool player?

Treat mindset as a way to run practice, not a way to win. In one 2025 survey of 490 Chinese university athletes (Deng and colleagues, Frontiers in Psychology), stronger growth mindset went with stronger competitive motivation (r = 0.48). It was a single snapshot with self-reported answers, so it cannot show cause.

Pool was not among the sports studied, which included basketball, badminton, and gymnastics. So the honest reading is this: the belief may help you stay in the work of getting better, and we found no study showing it makes pool players win more often. The cost of trying it is a notebook and ten minutes.

Try this at your next match

  1. Name the miss in one fact. After a missed shot, say or write what happened: "I hit the cut too thin." Skip the verdict, such as "I choke."
  2. Ask one question. Write what you would change next time. One change, not five.
  3. Pick one shot you avoid. Spend ten minutes before the match on it, even if you miss most of them.
  4. Count tries, not only wins. Keep a tally of the hard shots you attempted. Look at it after the match.
  5. Run a four-week test. Compare your notes with your results.
Weekly email

Behind the Ball

A free weekly email: a recap of our new articles, tournaments coming up (STK’s and others’) and the pool news we shared.

One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.

Read next

FAQ

Is a growth mindset the same as positive thinking?

No. Per her publisher, Dweck describes it as the belief that abilities can be developed, which is not a forecast that you will win any given match.

Does the research prove mindset does not work?

No. The reviews above find weak average effects in school, and researchers disagree about whether at-risk groups gain more.

Does it apply to pool?

We found no pool study. The closest evidence is a survey of 490 university athletes in other sports, and it shows only a link.

What does d = 0.05 mean?

The letter d measures a difference in standard deviations. A value of 0.05 is one-twentieth of a standard deviation, which is close to no difference.

Should I read the book?

Read it as a persuasive argument, then weigh it against the meta-analyses. The book is the idea, and the reviews are the test.

Sources7